Loading…
Loading…
Compare the true financial cost of renting versus buying a home over a chosen time period. This calculator factors in mortgage payments, property taxes, maintenance, insurance, closing costs, home appreciation, rent increases, and the opportunity cost of investing your down payment elsewhere. Find the break-even point where buying becomes cheaper.
Recommendation
buy
Break-even Year
6
Total Rent Cost
$275,133.1
Final Home Equity
$292,955.9
In this scenario ($400,000 home, 20% down, 6.5% mortgage, and $2,000 starting rent), the model recommends buy, with break-even around year 6 and projected home equity of $292,955.9 after 10 years.
Source: FinCalc server-rendered example using the same formulas as the interactive calculator.
Over 10 years, this scenario suggests buying is cheaper with a total rent cost of $275,133.1 versus final home equity of $292,955.9, with break-even around year 6.
Recommendation
Buying is cheaper
Break-Even Year
Year 6
Total Rent Cost
$275,133.1
Home Equity
$292,955.9
| Year | Rent Net Cost | Buy Net Cost | Home Equity | Advantage |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | $17,560 | $28,994.69 | $97,576.72 | Rent +$11,434.69 |
| 2 | $35,389.2 | $45,567.84 | $115,882.98 | Rent +$10,178.64 |
| 3 | $53,477.64 | $61,697.04 | $134,951.98 | Rent +$8,219.4 |
| 4 | $71,813.82 | $77,358.58 | $154,818.57 | Rent +$5,544.76 |
| 5 | $90,384.5 | $92,527.37 | $175,519.39 | Rent +$2,142.87 |
| 6 | $109,174.64 | $107,176.86 | $197,092.96 | Buy +$1,997.79 |
| 7 | $128,167.2 | $121,278.95 | $219,579.72 | Buy +$6,888.25 |
| 8 | $147,342.94 | $134,803.89 | $243,022.25 | Buy +$12,539.04 |
| 9 | $166,680.3 | $147,720.19 | $267,465.28 | Buy +$18,960.11 |
| 10 | $186,155.18 | $159,994.48 | $292,955.9 | Buy +$26,160.7 |
FinCalc AI
FinCalc AI
Suggested questions:
Copy and paste this HTML to embed the Rent vs Buy Calculator on your site.
Direct answer: rent-vs-buy decisions are usually dominated by holding period, mortgage rate, and alternative investment return on down payment and monthly cash-flow differences.
Source context: Federal Reserve housing and mortgage datasets show rate shifts can move break-even timelines by multiple years even when home prices and rents stay similar.
The real cost of buying includes not just your mortgage payment, but property taxes (typically 0.5–2.5% of home value annually), maintenance (1% average), homeowner insurance, and closing costs. In return, you build equity as your home appreciates and mortgage principal is paid down. When renting, your down payment and closing costs can be invested instead. At a 7% average market return, this opportunity cost is significant. However, rent typically increases 3–5% per year, while a fixed-rate mortgage payment stays constant.
Buying is not always the better financial choice. Consider renting if:
The break-even year is when the net cost of buying (total spent minus home equity) becomes less than the net cost of renting (total rent minus investment gains on down payment). For most scenarios, this occurs between years 4 and 8. If you plan to move sooner, renting is often cheaper.
This model uses fixed annual rates for appreciation, rent increases, and investment returns. Real-world values fluctuate. Tax deductions (mortgage interest, property tax) are not included for simplicity — they would favor buying slightly more. Transaction costs of selling (5–6% agent fees) are also excluded.
With a $450,000 home, 20% down, and a 6.5% mortgage, renting is often cheaper over a 5-year horizon once closing and selling costs are included. Transaction costs alone can be 7% to 10% of home value, or about $31,500 to $45,000. Buying tends to improve when you stay long enough to spread those costs over more years.
A common break-even range is 7 to 12 years for buyers with 6% to 7% mortgage rates and 3% home appreciation assumptions. For example, on a $400,000 home with 20% down and $2,100 rent alternative, break-even might occur near year 9. Faster rent growth and stronger appreciation can move break-even earlier.
At 6.5% with 20% down, principal and interest on $400,000 is about $2,530 per month before taxes and insurance. Adding 1.2% property tax and $1,500 annual insurance brings total housing cost near $3,160 per month. Using a 28% front-end ratio, that implies about $135,000 annual gross income.
A larger down payment lowers mortgage interest, but it also increases opportunity cost if that cash could earn returns elsewhere. For instance, an extra $50,000 invested at 7% grows to about $98,400 in 10 years. You should compare reduced mortgage cost against the foregone investment growth using the same timeframe.
It depends on your timeline, location, and opportunity cost. Buying includes mortgage, property tax, maintenance, and insurance; renting avoids those but rent typically rises 3–5% yearly. For most scenarios the break-even point (when buying becomes cheaper in net cost) falls between years 4 and 8. Use this calculator with your numbers to compare.
Buying usually makes sense when you plan to stay 7+ years, can afford the down payment without sacrificing emergency savings, and when local rent growth outpaces home appreciation assumptions. The break-even year depends on mortgage rate, rent level, property tax, and investment return on your down payment.
Mortgage Early Payoff
Calculate how extra payments reduce your mortgage term and total interest paid. Supports annuity and differentiated payment schedules.
House Affordability Calculator
Estimate max home price using debt ratios, down payment, mortgage rate, and state-specific property tax assumptions.
HOA Cost Calculator
Total HOA cost over 10–30 years with growth and special assessments. See what condo dues really cost.
Roommate Rent Split Calculator
Fair rent division by room size and private bath. Split by sq ft with amenity premium.
Rent Budget Calculator
How much rent can you afford? 30% rule: max rent = 30% of gross income. 25% conservative, 35% stretch.
Down Payment Savings Calculator
How long to save for a home down payment? Target, current savings, monthly contribution, expected return. Year-by-year projection.